Home | Databases | WorldLII | Search | Feedback Edited Legal Collections Data

Walle, Simon Vande --- "What keeps plaintiffs away from the court? An analysis of antitrust litigation in Japan, Europe and the US" [2014] ELECD 486; in Vanoverbeke, Dimitri; Maesschalck, Jeroen; Nelken, David; Parmentier, Stephan (eds), "The Changing Role of Law in Japan" (Edward Elgar Publishing, 2014) 209

Book Title: The Changing Role of Law in Japan

Editor(s): Vanoverbeke, Dimitri; Maesschalck, Jeroen; Nelken, David; Parmentier, Stephan

Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing

ISBN (hard cover): 9781783475643

Section: Chapter 13

Section Title: What keeps plaintiffs away from the court? An analysis of antitrust litigation in Japan, Europe and the US

Author(s): Walle, Simon Vande

Number of pages: 20

Abstract/Description:

Litigation is said to be less frequent in Japan than in other developed countries. In popular discourse and in some scholarship, this is often attributed to Japanese culture and, more specifically, Japanese society's negative attitude towards litigation. This idea is part of the 'classical view' on the role of law and litigation in Japan described in the introduction to the book. For decades scholars have debated whether this idea is a myth or reality (e.g., Haley 1978, Cole 2007) but no consensus has emerged. Perhaps this should come as no surprise, since litigation occurs in response to very diverse types of conflict. The factors that determine whether people go to court are different depending on whether they are facing a divorce, a traffic accident, a patent dispute or environmental pollution (cf. Murayama 2009, pp. 277, 284-5). Hence, identifying the impact of culture - however defined - on the volume of litigation as a whole is probably an impossible task. Instead, focusing on specific types of litigation is more likely to allow us to identify the factors that determine litigation rates. In line with this idea, this chapter examines a specific type of litigation, namely private lawsuits in response to violations of antitrust law (competition law) or, in short, private antitrust litigation. Through this lens, the chapter challenges the classical view on Japanese litigiousness and the role of culture.