Home | Databases | WorldLII | Search | Feedback Edited Legal Collections Data

Niblett, Anthony --- "Delaying declarations of constitutional invalidity" [2017] ELECD 561; in Fagan, Frank; Levmore, Saul (eds), "The Timing of Lawmaking" (Edward Elgar Publishing, 2017) 299

Book Title: The Timing of Lawmaking

Editor(s): Fagan, Frank; Levmore, Saul

Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing

ISBN (hard cover): 9781785364327

Section: Chapter 13

Section Title: Delaying declarations of constitutional invalidity

Author(s): Niblett, Anthony

Number of pages: 23

Abstract/Description:

What is so special about the timing of a judicial decision? When a court finds a statute to be unconstitutional and strikes down the law, from what time does the law cease to have effect? More importantly, when should the law cease to have effect? Three timing possibilities emerge. First, the law in question has no force or effect from the time of the judicial decision. Second, the law is deemed to never have been valid. A third possibility is the subject of this chapter. Suppose the point of invalidity occurs at some time in the future. The court holds the law to be unconstitutional, but suspends its declaration of invalidity for some period of time, perhaps one year. The unconstitutional law remains on the books and in effect during the time period following the court’s decision, but if the legislature does not address the unconstitutional defect by the judicially imposed deadline, then the declaration of invalidity takes effect. Despite the fact that individuals and groups may be deprived of constitutional rights, I argue that there are good reasons to delay declarations of invalidity in some circumstances. The delay may significantly mitigate transition costs associated with legal change and can provide the option to avoid potentially wasteful investments. But this delay can also change the judicial game between the courts and the legislature. Governments will be less proactive in ensuring that laws comply with the constitution and courts will be less likely to uphold statutes and regulations. Keywords: timing, judicial review, invalidity, unconstitutional laws, delay, deadlines, transitions