Home | Databases | WorldLII | Search | Feedback Edited Legal Collections Data

Riley, Sophie --- "Wildlife law and animal welfare: competing interests and ethics" [2019] ELECD 1094; in Scholtz, Werner (ed), "Animal Welfare and International Environmental Law" (Edward Elgar Publishing, 2019) 148

Book Title: Animal Welfare and International Environmental Law

Editor(s): Scholtz, Werner

Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing

Section: Chapter 4

Section Title: Wildlife law and animal welfare: competing interests and ethics

Author(s): Riley, Sophie

Number of pages: 32

Abstract/Description:

Wildlife law and concepts of animal welfare evolved at different times, for different reasons and along different pathways. Few treaty systems broach wildlife welfare, while at the national level, regimes cover a plethora of wildlife law and animal welfare issues, yet the two systems remain largely disengaged. Early welfare laws predominantly applied to domesticated animals, initiating a disconnect that became entrenched by management practices that classified animals in a useful/harmful dichotomy. Wildlife was thus seen as the problem, with little acknowledgement that many human–wildlife conflicts are, in reality, conflicts among humans and their differing uses of wildlife. It was also rare that balancing conflicts involved significant consideration of animal welfare. Using examples from Australian wildlife law, focusing on New South Wales, the chapter evaluates the relationship between policy, legislation and the lack of weight given to animal welfare in wildlife management. Deficiencies that are evident at both national and international levels suggest that an international solution would be appropriate. While proposals in the literature include expanding the purview of existing treaty systems and establishing a new international organization for animal welfare, the emerging concept of compassionate conservation shows the most promise for integrating animal well-being into wildlife regimes.